
Gym Class Heroes f/ The-Dream - Cookie Jar
Today’s post is brought to you by Johnathan Kochis of Concerning This. It is the second in a series of guilty pleasures, as submitted by other writers. The first entry can be read here.
If it wasn’t for the chubby R&B singer with the search-engine optimized name, I probably would have never been a fan of this Gym Class Heroes song “Cookie Jar”. With a Tricky Stewart beat backed by an electric guitar, and “cookie” being used as a metaphor for females and their pussies (I mean it rhymes with cookie, come on), it can seem pretty cheesy. But despite the ill-advised biting of Raekwon‘s “Ice Cream”, it somehow works. You have The-Dream who can make a hit single out of a hook, kinda like a rhythm and blues MacGuyver, and Travis McCoy who can…uh…toss around half-assed lines about how eating cookies is kinda like being unfaithful and/or promiscuous.
But listening to this song makes me ask some important questions:
1. Why do I not feel guilty about enjoying this song?: I was asked to write about a guilty pleasure song. Something that I might have even deleted from my last.fm page. But that’s not the case with “Cookie Jar”. And even if I knew how to delete the presence of “Cookie Jar” from my last.fm charts, I wouldn’t. What’s there to be ashamed about? I like females, cookies, The-Dream, and synthesizers. This song has all of those elements. But there has to be something more, a better reason as to why I like this song so much. And I found it: I was drunk the first time I listened to it.
I was a passenger in a car in Florida, alcohol coursing through my veins and this song came on the radio and told those cheap speakers “You Better Work”, minus RuPaul. I thought to myself in that intoxicated moment, “this song would be great to hear in the club, or when you were drunk” (I’m a deep thinker when I have some liquor in me). So I think that is why I enjoy this song so much. I am biased towards it. It played while I was having a good ole time and when I hear it, it takes me back to that moment.
2. When Mr. McCoy raps about leaving crumbs in the bed, what exactly does he mean?: Are crumbs code for condoms? Are they those sexual stains that you have to scrub out of clothing? I have a feeling that we’ll never really know.
3. What kind of cookies are “caucasians”?: And also, what kind of females are “Thin Mints”?
4. Is this song about Katy Perry?: Did Travis cheat on her for some trans fat having groupies?
5. Was LL Cool J’s classic “Pink Cookies” the inspiration for this song?: See here.
6. I heard no mention of contraception or proper dental hygiene habits in this song: Are the Gym Class Heroes responsible for our health?